An insurance umpire is the neutral third party who decides the disputed items when the two appraisers in a property insurance appraisal can’t agree. TX Insurance Appraiser provides umpire services across Texas — reviewing both appraisers’ positions, inspecting when needed, and signing a reasoned award on the amount of loss.
What does an insurance umpire do?
Most Texas appraisal clauses provide that the two appraisers select a competent, impartial umpire. The umpire only steps in on the items the appraisers cannot resolve. An award signed by the umpire and either appraiser becomes binding as to the amount of loss. Read more in what does an insurance umpire do?
- Reviews each appraiser’s estimate, photos, measurements and reports
- Holds a conference or hearing with both appraisers
- Inspects the property when the evidence calls for it
- Decides each disputed line item and signs the award with one appraiser
How umpires are chosen in Texas
The appraisers usually agree on an umpire within a set period — often 15 days. If they can’t, either party may ask a court of record in the county where the property is located to appoint one. Our guide on how insurance umpires are chosen in Texas covers the process in detail.
What makes a good appraisal umpire?
| Quality | Why it matters |
|---|---|
| Impartiality | No financial interest in the outcome and no disqualifying relationship with either side. |
| Construction knowledge | Able to evaluate roofing, framing, finishes and code requirements on the merits. |
| Estimating fluency | Comfortable reading Xactimate and Symbility line items and pricing. |
| Clear communication | Explains decisions so both sides understand the award. |
Umpire services throughout Texas
We accept umpire appointments for residential and commercial appraisals in Houston, Dallas, Austin, San Antonio, Fort Worth and cities statewide. To preserve impartiality, we do not serve as umpire on any claim where we have represented either party.
When appraisers reach an impasse
An impasse isn’t a failure — it’s exactly what the umpire provision is for. Understanding what an impasse means and what happens if appraisers disagree helps both sides prepare clear, well-supported submissions.
